Keywords
History of medicine
Health services
Abstract
The Health and Care Act 2022 affirmed the ‘primacy of place’ in the National Health Service (NHS) through major structural reforms replacing General Practitioner (GP) led Clinical Commissioning Groups (CCGs) with 42 Integrated Care Boards (ICBs). The intention behind the Act was to strengthen engagement between the NHS, local authorities, and other stakeholders in place-based systems providing collaborative, integrated health and social care services across organisational and financial boundaries. This reversed longstanding political commitment to competition. However, identical intentions – about facilitating consensus, cooperation and cost-effectiveness between health and social services – underpinned the first major reorganisation of the NHS in 1974. Drawing upon a unique central government file dedicated to the problems the reorganisation raised for South Westmorland, this paper explores the gap between neat structural reforms imagined by the centre and their messy realisation in the periphery, highlighting similar tensions in the present.
References
Department of Health and Social Care. Integration and innovation: working together to improve health and social care for all. London: Department of Health and Social Care; 2021. Available from: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/960549/integration-and-innovation-working-together-to-improve-health-and-social-care-for-all-print-version.pdf. [Accessed 23rd June 2021].
Lancashire and South Cumbria Health and Care Partnership. Delivering integrated care in Lancashire and South Cumbria. Available from: https://www.healthierlsc.co.uk/integratedcare. [Accessed 2nd July 2022].
Paton C. NHS reform and health politics in the UK: revolution, counter-revolution and Covid crisis. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan; 2022.
Webster C. National Health Service reorganisation: learning from history? London: Office of Health Economics; 1998.
Alderwick H, Dunn P, Gardner T, Mays N, Dixon J. Will a new NHS structure in England help recovery from the pandemic? British Medical Journal. 2021;372(n248). Available from: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.n248.
Gorsky M. The British National Health Service, 1948-2008: a review of the historiography. Social History of Medicine. 2008;21(3):437-460. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1093/shm/hkn064.
Watkin B. The National Health Service: the first phase, 1948-1974 and after. London: George Allen and Unwin; 1978.
Merrison A. Royal Commission on the National Health Service. London: HMSO; 1979.
Lambert M. Lancashire and South Cumbria New Hospitals Programme: once in a generation or generation gap? Morecambe Bay Medical Journal. 2021;8(10):284-287. Available from: https://doi.org/10.48037/mbmj.v8i10.1313
Moser CA, Scott W. British towns: a statistical study of their social and economic differences. Edinburgh: Oliver and Boyd; 1961.
Marshall JD. The County Council in retrospect. In: Marshall JD, McClintock ME (eds.) The history of Lancashire County Council, 1889 to 1974. London: Martin Robertson; 1977: 363-387.
Lambert M. Problems of practising public health in Westmorland: John A. Guy as County Medical Officer, 1946-70. Morecambe Bay Medical Journal. 2022;9(1): 27-31. Available from: https://doi.org/10.48037/mbmj.v9i1.1360
Means R, Morbey H, Smith R. From community care to market care? The development of welfare services for older people. Bristol: Policy Press; 2002.
Griffith JAG. Central departments and local authorities. London: George Allen and Unwin; 1966.
Hill MJ. The sociology of public administration. London: Weidenfeld and Nicholson; 1972.
Bulpitt JG. Party politics in English local government. London: Longman; 1967.
Lambert M. Fortunate men or penny collectivists? General practice in Lancashire and Westmorland during the “classic” NHS. Morecambe Bay Medical Journal. 2021;8(11): 301-305. Available from: https://doi.org/10.48037/mbmj.v8i11.1326
Lewis J. What price community medicine? The philosophy, practice and politics of public health since 1919. Brighton: Wheatsheaf; 1986.
Marshall JD. The government of Lancashire from 1889: its roots and characteristics. In: Marshall JD, McClintock ME (eds.) The history of Lancashire County Council, 1889 to 1974. London: Martin Robertson; 1977:3-22.
Lambert M. The vices of patronage for health services under reform. History & Policy. Policy Paper. Available from: https://www.historyandpolicy.org/policy-papers/papers/the-vices-of-patronage-for-health-services-under-reform. [Accessed 21 July 2021].
Pickstone JV. Medicine and industrial society: a history of hospital development in Manchester and its region, 1752-1946. Manchester: Manchester University Press; 1985.
Lambert M. Medical education, workforce inequalities, and hierarchical regionalism: Lancaster University and the unrealised medical school, 1964-68. Morecambe Bay Medical Journal. 2022;8(12): 342-346. Available from: https://doi.org/10.48037/mbmj.v8i12.1345
Deakin N. The perils of partnership: the voluntary sector and the state, 1945-1992. In: Davis Smith J, Rochester C, Hedley R (eds.) An introduction to the voluntary sector. London: Routledge; 1995: 40-65.
Stewart MEH. Unpaid public service: a local Fabian Societies analysis of the membership of local authorities and regional hospital boards. London: Fabian Society; 1964.
Finlayson G. Citizen, state and social welfare in Britain, 1830-1990. Oxford: Clarendon Press; 1994.
Webster C. The health services since the War, Volume I: Problems of health care. The National Health Service before 1957. London: HMSO; 1988.
Begley P, Sheard S, Mackillop E. (eds.) The 1974 NHS reorganisation: a witness seminar transcript. Liverpool: University of Liverpool Department of Public Health and Policy; 2018.
Begley P, Sheard S. McKinsey and the “tripartite monster”: the role of management consultants in the 1974 NHS reorganisation. Medical History. 2019;63(4): 390-410. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1017/mdh.2019.41
Webster C. The health services since the war. Volume II: Government and health care. The National Health Service, 1958-1979. London: HMSO; 1996.
Allsop J, May A. The emperor’s new clothes: Family Practitioner Committees in the 1980s. London: King’s Fund; 1986.
Edwards B. A manager’s tale, 1946-1992. London: Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust; 1993.
Welshman J. Inequalities, regions and hospitals: the Resource Allocation Working Party’. In: Gorsky M, Sheard S (eds.) Financing medicine: the British experience since 1750. London: Routledge; 2006: 221-240.
Wood B. The process of local government reform, 1966-74. London: Allen and Unwin; 1976.
Cockburn C. The local state: management of cities and people. London: Pluto Press; 1977.
Johnes M. Inventing a county: Cardiff, South Glamorgan and the 1974 reorganisation of local government. Welsh History Review. 2007;23(2): 153-174.
Seebohm F. Report of the committee on local authority and allied personal social services. London: HMSO; 1968.
Cooper J. The creation of the British personal social services, 1962-1974. London: Heinemann; 1983.
Brown RGS. The management of welfare: a study of British social service administration. London: Fontana; 1975.
Hall P. Reforming the welfare: the politics of change in the personal social services. London: Heinemann; 1976.
The National Archives: Local Commission for England (Hancock Commission): Merseyside and South East Lancashire and North Western General Review Areas, 1961-65. T 183/7.
Redcliffe-Maud JP. Royal Commission on Local Government in England. London: HMSO; 1969.
The National Archives: Royal Commission on Local Government in England (Redcliffe-Maud Commission): Evidence: Westmorland County Council, 1966-69. HLG 69/50.
Westmorland County Council. Annual report of the County Medical Officer of Health, 1948. Kendal: Westmorland County Council; 1949.
The National Archives: Newcastle-upon-Tyne Regional Hospital Board: Special Area Committee for Cumberland and North Westmorland, 1950-55. MH 88/11.
Mohan J. Planning, markets and hospitals. London: Routledge; 2002.
Ministry of Health. A hospital plan for England and Wales. London: HMSO; 1962.
Cumbria Archive Service Barrow: Cumbria Area Health Authority: Correspondence and reports on new Furness General Hospital, 1960-82. BTCAHA/2/1.
The National Archives: Department of Health and Social Security: NHS reorganisation: Inter regional arrangements for the provision of health services: boundary overlap zone problem in the South Westmorland area, 1972-79. MH 160/1108.
Department of Health and Social Security. National Health Service reorganisation. HRC(73)4. London: Department of Health and Social Security; 1973.
Cumbria Archive Service Barrow: Cumbria Area Health Authority: Reorganisation of districts, 1974. BTCAHA/1/30.
Chin PL, Chatterjee J, Denham T, Ridley JM. Speciality budgeting: a pilot study carried out in East Cumbria Health District. Health Trends. 1981;13(1): 22-25.
Cumbria County Council. Cumbria local government reorganisation case for change. Carlisle: Cumbria County Council; 2020. Available from: https://www-cloudfront.allerdale.gov.uk/media/filer_public/be/d0/bed056b7-e0a2-49d5-a074-c711e0df1864/lgr_cumbria_east_and_west_final.pdf [accessed 2nd July 2022].
Lancashire and South Cumbria Integrated Care Board. Our geography and population. Available from: https://www.lancashireandsouthcumbria.icb.nhs.uk/about-us/welcome-lancashire-and-south-cumbria [accessed 8th August 2022].